Our Team

Jay Cavaiani
Lead Pastor
I am so thankful you are checking out our website. I hope to meet you. I love to meet people for coffee at Mama D’s which is attached to our church. Please let me know if you would like to visit.
A little about our family:
Kelly and I have been married for 24 years. Praise the Lord! Our oldest Jacob works for NBC nightly news in New York City. Abby, our middle child, goes to Missouri State and is a golfer. My youngest son Caleb is graduating Kettle Moraine High School in June of 2020. Kelly and I live not far from church in a little house in the woods. We love to hike, jog, most things outdoors, and we both enjoy golf.
I would love to share with you a little about my perspective on the church and the churches mission. I believe wholeheartedly in our mission to equip believers to be fruitful and it influences the way I teach and preach on Sundays. I desire to provide rich, in-depth teaching focused on God’s Word where people learn something of substance that helps them believe, mature, and bear fruit for God. Although we are a church for anyone looking to discover Jesus or grow in Him, we unashamedly exist to equip believers to be fruitful. We seek to serve meat and not just milk. We desire for people to leave a Sunday service feeling challenged, equipped, and encouraged to live for Jesus. Our church does an amazing job welcoming new people and our size (150ish seat sanctuary) and comfortable setting fosters people becoming part of our family quickly. With that said, we are not seeking first to be a seeker sensitive church, but rather a church that is first focused on equipping the believer. We think even seekers sense something inauthentic in churches when worship feels like a rock concert and the Sunday service that feels like a scripted performance. We want our draw to be the teaching of God’s inspired Word with the help of the Holy Spirit.
We hope you come visit! When you do our desire is to provide you with a warm and sincere welcome in a comfortable setting that helps you get excited that you may have just found a church home. Finally, and even more importantly, we hope when you get in your car and reflect on your experience that you feel you have been spiritually impacted by the teaching of God’s Word and desiring to come back again soon.
Matt Kraft
Associate Pastor -Intern
My name is Matt and welcome to Crossing!
My wife, Danielle and I have six kids.  As a family we love being outdoors, hiking & camping.  I enjoy hunting, fishing and studying God’s Word. As an Associate Pastor Intern here I run the Men’s Bible study group and occasionally do Wednesday Night and Sunday morning sermons. I am currently seeking out Moody Bible Institute for my certificate in Biblical studies and will continue schooling as God leads me. I feel very blessed and honored to be here. I look forward to meeting you!
Nikki Streit
Office Administrator
Nikki and her husband Dan have been married since 2005. They have Irish Twin boys Carson and Mason (11 months apart). Before children she had worked for an OB/GYN Specialist as a Medical Transcriptionist and stayed home for 8 years to care for the boys. 
Nikki and Dan were married in Negril, Jamaica. They also have two rescue dogs, Braun and Meike. Their family loves spending time together, Brewers Baseball, Green Bay Packer Football and traveling. 
Danielle Kraft
Campus Way Youth Leader / Coordinator
& Office Assistant
Hi! I’m Danielle and I am leader and coordinator of Campus Way. I also help out within the church helping Nikki in the office and running the websites both for the church and Campus Way. My husband Matt and I have been married since 2012 and we have six children whom we homeschool. Our three oldest attend Campus Way as well and it has been such a blessing in our lives.  As a family we enjoy hiking, camping, four-wheeling and having family movie nights. Kids have always been a part of my life. I went to school for Early Childhood and then worked for over 10 years with kids in a learning center. I’m enjoying working with the middle and High school students and challenging them to think deep. My goal with these students is to know Christ and make Him known. We study God’s word each week, seeking with open hearts. We learn how Jesus dealt with every life situation possible and then how we can apply it to ourselves as we continue to grow and become Christ-like disciples.  I also want to have a parent to parent relationship and come along side you as we walk through life and be a support for you and your Kids. Please let me know if you have any questions or if you would like to meet for coffee at our favorite Mama D’s next door to Church!
Check out the Campus Way website for more information @ campusway.org
Sara Wiesner
Kids Crossing Coordinator
Sara is our Kids Crossing Coordinator.  Sara and her husband, Bud, started dating in high school and have been married since 2001.  Together they have 6 children, which they homeschool, and a dog named Figment.  In her free time she enjoys Bible study, crafting and spending quality time with family and friends.  Sara and her family have loved being part of the Crossing Community Church family, and she is honored to have the opportunity to impact children for the Kingdom of God and help the Bible come alive to them.